Is Blackstone griddle coating coming off? (Quick Fix)

Only Blackstone users can understand my feelings when I found that my beloved griddle had started

It was annoying to find flakes in my delicious smash burger and I knew I had to do something
about it.

Luckily, with a little reseasoning and extra care, Blackstone griddles can last a lifetime.

In this guide, you will learn about:

— Reasons for Blackstone peeling

–How to fix and resurface a Blackstone griddle

blackstone griddle coating coming off
Blackstone griddle coating coming off

Blackstone Griddle Coating Coming Off?

If you are a Blackstone griddle lover like me, you want to know how you can fix your chipped Blackstone griddle.

Along with reasons for why black coating is coming off your Blackstone griddle, I will also share
how you can clean and reseason it. Sometimes just seasoning does not cut it, and you may need to strip and resurface to salvage your griddle as well. Maintaining your Blackstone griddle is the perfect cure to this dilemma and preventing future griddle pains.

Why is my Blackstone griddle peeling?

What is my Blackstone Griddle peeling?

The first step is to decode the black coating coming off your Blackstone griddle. When you first bought your Blackstone griddle, you must have prepped it for use through proper cleaning and seasoning. Sometimes, that seasoning starts flaking off and the griddle eventually needs to be scraped off and then reseasoned.

For starters, you should understand how to season and prepare your Blackstone griddle so that it stays on for longer cooks.

To that end, read my Starter Guide to Blackstone Griddles.

Next, let’s go through several factors that may cause your Blackstone griddle to catch rust or start peeling. 

1- Poor Seasoning: If the griddle was not properly seasoned before use or if the seasoning has worn off over time, the surface of the griddle may start to peel. Some seasonings like bacon fat have a high sodium and phosphate content. These additives can create weak seasoning and makes your griddle flake earlier.

2- Using Salt: If you have been using a lot of salt in your recipes or using it to clean the griddle surface then that is one of the main causes for Blackstone’s flaking. Salt causes seasoning to dry up and chip off quickly.

3- Use of abrasive cleaning products: If you use harsh or abrasive cleaning products on the griddle, it can damage the surface and cause it to peel.

4- Thick Seasoning: The first layer of oil may be too thick for seasoning to bind properly causing Blackstone peeling to occur. While seasoning the Blackstone griddle, you need to smoke it off for half an hour before you coat it with oil.

5- Using Soap: Soap is a degreaser that can break down the seasoning layer and chip it off prematurely.

Here are 15 Common Blackstone Griddle Problems (With Solutions) for your knowledge.

How to fix Blackstone peeling?

The only way to prevent burned Blackstone peeling and flaking on your griddle is through its timely cleaning.

However, if you find yourself in that unbearable situation, you need to know how to repair the griddle top and bring it back to its former glory.

Tools you need:

It is worth investing in some maintenance for your griddle. Here are a few must-have accessories you may need for fixing the black coating coming off the Blackstone griddle.

Spade and Spatula:


This spatula and spade set will not only help you in cooking but also plays a major role in cleaning the griddle. If you own a flat-top griddle, you cannot live without this kit. These metal spades and spatulas are a must-have for scraping off the Blackstone flaking.

Scouring Scrubbers:

This pack of 10 retails at a cheap price on Amazon and is a great investment for easily scrubbing off burnt Blackstone peeling.

Grill Stone: These pumice stones are a must-have during the reseasoning process. It does not absorb the gunk; hence, it can be used for several cleanings. It is also non-abrasive which prevents damaging the griddle.

This griddle conditioner is the top-selling one on Amazon and retails at the cheapest rate as well. It creates a slick and non-stick griddle surface which prevents Blackstone flaking and rust from developing for longer periods.

Paint and Rust Scraper:
L3M Paint and Rust Stripper
This rust stripper is designed so it follows the contours of your griddle top to create an even surface after the job is done. The strong disc shape cuts through griddle peelings quickly and strips through evenly.

Orbital Sander:
It is compact yet a high-efficiency cleaning tool. This sander comes with a built-in dust collection bag to collect all the flakes and dust while you use it.


Reseasoning your Blackstone Griddle:

Step 1: Turn on your Blackstone griddle at a high setting for a little while. Once the surface is hot, use a metal scraper from your griddle spatula set and scrape off the burnt Blackstone peeling.

Make sure to use even pressure so you can scrape off an even layer of the flakes. Do not leave any chips or cracks on the griddle surface before moving to the next step. Take your time!

Step 2: Let the griddle cool down before cleaning off all the flakes with a paper towel or scouring pad.

Step 3: Now add 2-3 tablespoons of canola on the griddle surface.

Step 4: Take your grill pumice stone and start working on the griddle top till the black coating from the Blackstone griddle is completely removed.

Use even pressure and a circular motion to scrub your griddle top smoothly. The aim is to resurface the griddle with an even look so be sure to focus on the cracked areas more.

Don’t forget the sides and edges!

Step 5: Clean up the oil with a metal scraper and remove the remaining gunk with paper towels. Keep repeating steps 3 and 4 if you feel the Blackstone griddle flaking has not been scrubbed off completely. Once clean, move on to Step 6.

Step 6: Reseason your Blackstone griddle evenly to prevent future Blackstone peelings.

Can you resurface a Blackstone griddle?

Sometimes the damage to your griddle is far beyond reseasoning but it is never beyond salvaging. Even with the worst Blackstone griddle paint peeling job, stripping down your griddle and resurfacing it is always possible.

  1. To strip your Blackstone griddle, fix a paint and rust stripper with a power drill to quickly cut through all the flaking and chippings. Take your time while doing this to make sure all the gunk is gone.
  2. Use a face mask and hand gloves as a precaution for this next step.
  3. Take your orbital sander to clean away any residue of Blackstone griddle flaking. Stop when you reach the original surface of your griddle.
  4. To resurface your griddle, you will follow similar steps as that of reseasoning. Use the reseasoning oil in thin, even layers and on high heat to reinstall your griddle for future use.
  5. Remember, the seasoning needs to be spread in a thin layer always, otherwise, your griddle will chip off sooner than expected and you shall be back to square one.

Prevention is the cure

The only way to prevent Blackstone lid paint from peeling off is to clean it after every use.

The problem occurs only when you let the gunk build-up by never cleaning up after cooking on it. Seasoning it regularly is also essential for keeping your Blackstone griddle from peeling.

Always use a metal scraper to evenly scrape off the food gunk and oil build-up on your griddle top after you are done cooking your favorite Blackstone smash burgers or any other recipe.

After you are done with the scraping, squirt some water on the griddle top and use paper towels to clean the gunk thoroughly.

You can repeat this step multiple times to completely clean your griddle top.

Cleaning while the Blackstone griddle is off but still hot makes the whole cleaning process much easier. And before you close the lid on your Blackstone, spread a thin and even layer of canola oil on the top to prepare for the next meal you cook.

Let’s wrap it up!

Do not beat yourself up if you face Blackstone griddle flaking and peeling issues. It happens to most professional chefs as well.

One cannot always clean and oil the griddle top properly because life happens! You may be in a rush to serve your guests or slice that warm brisket bark and forget to clean up.

Just remember, no matter how extensive the Blackstone peeling damage is, your Blackstone griddle will always be salvageable and good for use after stripping and resurfacing.

Leave a Reply